
I've always been a bit of a fence-sitter when it comes to the whole "Mac vs PC" thing. Having worked for some years in the professional audio industry I've come to appreciate the stability of Macs when used as the core of a DAW or digital studio. I'm also very aware of their shortcomings, and I often find myself missing the simple things I can do on my PC when using a Mac. I'm definitely a PC user, but I appreciate the strength of Apple for certain applications.
I also own an iPhone (3GS 16GB if you care), and I think it's great. As a mobile device/smartphone, it's fantastically functional, and while some of the idiosyncrasies (such as the lack of Flash support) can be irritating, overall it's pretty much the greatest phone I've ever had. No hyperbole.
All of this is preamble to the question I find myself asking this morning, following the
much anticipated release of the Apple iPad. And that question is:
"Why would I want to buy one of these?"
I can't see any reason to purchase an iPad other than sheer "must-have" mentality. Sure, it looks very nice, all slick lines and shiny glass (I'm not being facetious here, these are things that I really appreciate on the iPhone), but can it actually fulfil any of its
raisons d'etre better than the alternative devices on the market?
The answer, simply is no. Let's look at
how Apple are touting it. "The best way to experience the web, email, photos and video. Hands down"Whoa there, Steve. That's some pretty big talk there. But I'm guessing since you're saying these things, that this new device must be at least as good as, if not better than, the highest-end browsers and web interfaces, and offer total functionality?
Unfortunately not. For me, the best way to experience the web is for all the elements on any page I choose to visit to be available to me. And since the iPad, like the iPhone and iPod touch, offers no support for Adobe Flash, users had better get used to seeing this little icon. A LOT.

While we're on the subject, the lack of Flash also somewhat scuppers the whole "best way to experience video" claim, as something like 80% of the web's video is flash based. So no Hulu, DailyMotion, Google Video, Vimeo, Megavideo...basically anything that's not YouTube.
Speaking of video, I don't consider 4:3 to represent "the best way to experience" it. That's right folks, the iPad's display is in that quaint, but horrendously outdated format. Must be Jobs' tip of the hat to "retro". I'm joking of course. But it's still in 4:3, and no amount of wishing it was 16:9 or 16:10 is gonna make it so.
How about "the best way to experience email", then?
Well, like many people, a significant percentage of the emails I receive contain attachments. Audio files, office documents, spreadsheets and so forth. And while I am pleased to see that it apparently offers file attachment support (a step up from the mail application on the iPhone), it's limited to certain document types: .jpg, .tiff, .gif (images); .doc and .docx (Microsoft Word); .htm and .html (web pages); .key (Keynote); .numbers (Numbers); .pages (Pages); .pdf (Preview and Adobe Acrobat); .ppt and .pptx (Microsoft PowerPoint); .txt (text); .rtf (rich text format); .vcf (contact information); .xls and .xlsx (Microsoft Excel). This is actually pretty laudable, but it's hardly a comprehensive list of all the file types one might receive attached to an email. Notable by their absence from this list are compressed file types such as .rar or .zip, as well as many of the audio file types that I need to send and receive.
On the subject of audio files, I also note from
Apple's page of features, that it functions as an iPod as well. No problem with this
per se, except that I already own an iPhone 16GB, so I don't really need something four times the size to listen to my music collection, thanks.
So, you've used your iPad to download the attachments that you got sent in your email, and fortunately for you, they're just a couple of jpegs and a word document. Awesome! So, if you can just stick them on a USB memory stick, you can take a copy to pr... ...oh. Where's the USB port again? I mean, I see the ridiculous 30-pin proprietory Apple interface, sure, but... maybe it's on the back... no.
This has been, and remains my main gripe with Apple's products:
You are forced to use iTunes or other Apple software to interface with them. In the case of the iPhone it's particularly annoying, as by default you can only synchronise the content to
one computer (there are workarounds for this, in all fairness, but they are somewhat involved and complicated). I discovered this the hard way, when I had the smart idea of adding some of the mp3s from my work computer to the iPhone's library in addition to the 700 or so I'd put on already at home. iTunes was happy to do that for me, sure; and cheerfully wiped every song I'd already put on the thing. Thanks Apple! I can see how this would make life so much simpler for everyone! Why be troubled keeping all the data you've meticulously stored on a device previously when you can wipe it all at the touch of a button? Much easier, and a lot fewer of those annoying mp3s to have to manage. Sweet.
If Apple have designed the iPad in the same way (and with it running on iPhone OS, there's reason to believe they have), then this hammers the nail into its coffin as far as it having any use as a business device goes. First, you need to have remembered your interface cable. Next, the computer you want to connect to must have iTunes installed. (yeah, I can see
that being a popular idea with IT departments across the globe). Finally (and this part, I admit is conjecture), it might well "synchronise" your device with that copy of iTunes, clearing your files off it. I hope I'm wrong here.
Ahem. At this point I've just realised that I could go on about the lack of multitasking, the absence of any camera (after all, why would you want to use a $600 tablet computer for video conferencing, Skype or chat?), the maximum of 64GB storage space and so forth, but I don't want to start sounding whiny (I know, too late) - so I'll just say that while I can't see what I'd want it for, plenty of people are bound to buy it, use it and love it. And, no doubt, sit smugly on the underground, flaunting it.